This page covers franchised Subaru dealers in New York. Some operate as part of multi-franchise stores that carry additional brands under the same roof. They are included here because they hold an active Subaru franchise. Subaru dealers in New York average 4.68 stars across 40 stores and 72,212 reviews. That 4.68-star average is 0.11 stars above the national Subaru average (4.57) and 0.16 stars above the overall New York dealer average across all brands (4.52). Of the 40 Subaru stores in New York, 39 rate 4.5 stars or higher.
| Dealer | City | Rating | Reviews |
|---|---|---|---|
| West Herr Subaru of Orchard Park | Orchard Park | 4.80 | 5,886 |
| Romano Subaru | Syracuse | 4.80 | 5,573 |
| Goldstein Subaru | Colonie | 4.70 | 4,463 |
| Van Bortel Subaru of Rochester | Rochester | 4.90 | 3,871 |
| Van Bortel Subaru of Victor | Victor | 4.90 | 3,310 |
| Northtown Subaru | Amherst | 4.70 | 3,401 |
| Subaru White Plains | Elmsford | 4.70 | 3,398 |
| Subaru of Troy | Troy | 4.50 | 3,310 |
| Curry Subaru Kingston | Kingston | 4.80 | 2,630 |
| Grand Prix Subaru | Hicksville | 4.60 | 2,788 |
| Capitaland Subaru | Scotia | 4.70 | 2,252 |
| Island Subaru | Staten Island | 4.70 | 1,953 |
| West Herr Subaru of Rochester | Rochester | 4.80 | 1,855 |
| Brewster Subaru | Brewster | 4.80 | 1,840 |
| Mid Hudson Subaru | Wappingers Falls | 4.60 | 1,927 |
| Ruge's Subaru | Rhinebeck | 4.90 | 1,641 |
| Bill Rapp Subaru | Syracuse | 4.60 | 1,810 |
| Subaru of Utica | Yorkville | 4.60 | 1,640 |
| Matthews Subaru | Vestal | 4.70 | 1,442 |
| Five Star Subaru | Oneonta | 4.90 | 1,322 |
| Garber Chevrolet Subaru | Webster | 4.70 | 1,223 |
| Koeppel Subaru | Long Island City | 4.60 | 1,237 |
| DELLA Subaru | Plattsburgh | 4.80 | 1,107 |
| Bay Ridge Subaru | Brooklyn | 4.50 | 1,245 |
| Shults Subaru | Jamestown | 4.80 | 1,081 |
| Johnstons Subaru | Middletown | 4.50 | 1,172 |
| Maguire Subaru of Ithaca | Ithaca | 4.50 | 974 |
| Zappone Subaru Norwich | Norwich | 4.80 | 852 |
| Romeo Subaru | Saratoga Springs | 4.60 | 899 |
| Simmons-Rockwell Subaru | Elmira | 4.50 | 924 |
| Tasca Subaru | Yonkers | 4.70 | 824 |
| Fox Subaru | Auburn | 4.60 | 860 |
| West Herr Subaru of Lockport | Lockport | 4.90 | 730 |
| Star Subaru | Bayside | 4.50 | 643 |
| Royal Subaru | Cortland | 4.50 | 513 |
| North Country Subaru | Queensbury | 4.70 | 436 |
| Northtown Subaru Transit | Depew | 5.00 | 377 |
| Garber Subaru | Webster | 4.80 | 405 |
| Fuccillo Subaru | Watertown | 4.10 | 372 |
| Barstow Subaru | Potsdam | 4.60 | 26 |
The top-rated Subaru dealer in New York is West Herr Subaru of Orchard Park at 4.80 stars on 5,886 reviews.
Subaru dealers in New York have logged 72,212 total Google reviews across 40 stores, an average of 1,805 reviews per store.
Subaru dealers in other states: Subaru in Oklahoma | Subaru in Arkansas | Subaru in Delaware | Subaru in Nebraska | Subaru in Vermont | Subaru in Idaho | Subaru in West Virginia | Subaru in New Hampshire
Other brands in New York: Porsche in New York | Mazda in New York | McLaren in New York | Acura in New York | BMW in New York | Mercedes-Benz in New York | MINI in New York | Audi in New York
Subaru overview | New York overview
Source: DGActual Dealer Reviews Index, public Google ratings for 17,051 franchised dealers. Data as of 2026-10-10. Author: Daniel Govaer. Research support: Perplexity. Reuse with attribution and written consent, terms at dgactual.com/terms.html. See data.dgactual.com and reviews.dgactual.com. Open the live interactive scoreboard.